• SOC 2 Readiness
  • 24/7 incident line
  • 24/7 security operations team
Insurance Readiness

Cyber Insurance Readiness Checklist

Insurers ask about the same core controls at application and renewal. Check what you could answer yes to, truthfully and with evidence, before you fill in the questionnaire.

24 checks across 6 areas. Your answers stay in your browser.

Overall Progress

0 of 24 controls in place

0%

Prefer to talk it through? Talk to a vCISO

Treat the insurance questionnaire as a security review

Cyber insurance applications and renewal forms have become detailed security questionnaires. They ask whether MFA covers email, remote access and privileged accounts, whether endpoints run EDR, whether backups are isolated, how quickly you patch internet-facing systems, and whether you have a tested incident response plan. Each insurer words the questions differently and the requirements change over time, but the core topics are remarkably consistent.

This checklist is for CFOs, risk managers and IT leaders who are about to complete one of those forms. It helps you find out, before you sign, which answers you can give with confidence and which ones need work or a more careful explanation.

It is not a substitute for your insurer's actual questionnaire or your broker's advice. Use it to prepare: close the gaps you can before renewal, gather evidence for the controls you have, and go into the conversation with your broker knowing where you stand.

How to use the Cyber Insurance Readiness checklist

Work through it as a team exercise, not a solo quiz. The score is only as honest as the evidence behind each tick.
  1. Start early

    Run the checklist a few months before renewal, not the week the form is due. Some fixes, such as rolling out EDR or isolating backups, take time to do properly.
  2. Answer for every system

    Insurers often ask about all users or all endpoints. If MFA covers most accounts but not a shared mailbox or a legacy VPN, leave the item unticked until it does.
  3. Collect evidence as you go

    For each tick, save the screenshot, report or policy that proves it. That evidence pack makes the application faster and helps if questions arise at claim time.
  4. Review answers jointly

    Have IT and the person signing the application walk through the final answers together, and raise anything uncertain with your broker before submission.

Gaps we see most often

These are the items that most often turn out to be weaker than people expect once someone asks for evidence.

MFA with exceptions nobody listed

Service accounts, legacy protocols, a break-glass admin or an old VPN endpoint sit outside MFA, which makes an "all accounts" answer inaccurate.

Backups reachable with domain credentials

Backups are on separate storage, but the same administrator account that an attacker would steal can also delete them.

EDR without anyone watching

EDR is installed but alerts are reviewed only during business hours, or not at all, so a weekend intrusion runs unchallenged.

An incident plan that was never tested

A plan exists as a document, but nobody has rehearsed it or checked that it reflects the notice requirements and approved vendors in the policy.

What to do with your result

Focus on the critical items first. They line up with the questions underwriters most often treat as essential, and leaving one open can affect whether coverage is offered and on what terms. Your broker can tell you how a specific gap is likely to be viewed.

If you are close, the remaining work is usually evidence: documenting what you already do. If you are further away, our team can validate your controls, help close the gaps in a sensible order and prepare an evidence pack ahead of your application or renewal.

Cyber Insurance Readiness Checklist: Frequently Asked Questions

Why do insurers ask about these controls?

MFA, EDR, isolated backups and patching of internet-facing systems address the most common causes of costly claims, especially ransomware and business email compromise. Insurers use the questionnaire to price and decide coverage.

What happens if a questionnaire answer is wrong?

An inaccurate application can create problems when you make a claim. Treat the questionnaire as a security audit: only answer yes where you have evidence. Your broker and legal counsel can advise on your specific policy.

Which controls matter most?

The items marked critical: MFA on remote access, email and admin accounts, EDR on every endpoint, isolated and tested backups, prompt patching of internet-facing systems, and call-back verification for payment changes.

Does meeting every item guarantee coverage?

No. Each insurer sets its own requirements and also considers your industry, size, revenue and claims history. This checklist prepares you for the common questions; your broker can tell you what a particular insurer expects.

Do we need to use the insurer's incident response vendors?

Many policies include a panel of approved response firms and notice requirements. Check your policy before an incident, record the details in your response plan, and confirm with your broker whether using another firm is allowed.

Can GuardsArm help before renewal?

Yes. Our team can validate your controls, close gaps and help you assemble evidence ahead of your application or renewal.