• SOC 2 Readiness
  • 24/7 incident line
  • 24/7 security operations team

Free RFP template | Compliance

Compliance Audit RFP

Structured RFP template for hiring compliance audit firms. Supports SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA, PCI DSS, and NIST frameworks with framework-specific addendums.
Compliance audit
Pages
8
Sections
11
Fill-in fields
25
Scored criteria
5

What is inside

11 sections, ready to fill in

Each section opens with a short note on why it matters, followed by the wording and fill-in fields you complete before issuing.

  1. 01

    Project Overview & Compliance Framework(s)

    Name the framework and the version. Assessors scope very differently across them.

  2. 02

    Organisational Scope & Entity Boundaries

    Scope boundaries drive both cost and the usefulness of the resulting report. Be exact.

  3. 03

    Audit Type

    State what you are buying. Readiness work and attestation are different engagements with different independence rules.

  4. 04

    Framework-Specific Control Requirements

    List what you expect the assessor to cover so bids are comparable.

  5. 05

    Auditor Qualifications & Independence

    Independence is not optional and not always obvious. Ask directly.

  6. 06

    Evidence Collection & Documentation Standards

    Agree the evidence process up front; this is where audit effort is won or lost.

  7. 07

    Reporting Format & Remediation Support

    Specify the deliverable and ask for a sample. Report quality varies widely between firms.

  8. 08

    Timeline & Certification Deadline

    Make the hard deadline explicit and ask bidders to confirm capacity against it.

  9. 09

    Pricing & Travel Expense Structure

    Require an all-in figure. Audit engagements are prone to expense creep.

  10. 10

    Post-Audit Support & Continuous Monitoring

    Certification is a point in time; the obligation is continuous. Establish what happens afterwards.

  11. 11

    Submission Instructions

    How, when and to whom to submit, the response format, and the single point of contact for clarification questions.

When to use the Compliance Audit RFP

Use this RFP when you need an independent firm to assess you against a framework: a SOC 2 examination, an ISO/IEC 27001 certification audit, a PCI DSS assessment, or a HIPAA Security Rule assessment. It also works for readiness assessments and internal audits that come before the formal audit.

The most important decision comes before you write a word: who is allowed to perform the audit you need. A SOC 2 report must be issued by a licensed CPA firm. ISO/IEC 27001 certificates come from a certification body, ideally one accredited by a recognised accreditation body. PCI DSS Reports on Compliance are completed by a Qualified Security Assessor (QSA) company listed by the PCI Security Standards Council. HIPAA has no official certification at all, so any firm offering one is overstating what it can provide.

What to put in scope

Bidders can only price what you describe. Cover each of these in the scope section of the template.
  • The framework and version: for example SOC 2 against the 2017 Trust Services Criteria, ISO/IEC 27001:2022, or PCI DSS v4.0.1
  • The report type: SOC 2 Type 1 (design at a point in time) or Type 2 (operating effectiveness over a period), ISO stage 1 and stage 2 audits, or a PCI DSS Report on Compliance versus a self-assessment
  • For SOC 2, which Trust Services Criteria categories are in scope beyond Security, and the observation period you want
  • Legal entities, locations, systems, products and third parties in scope, plus subservice organizations and whether they are carved out or included
  • Whether you want a readiness assessment first, and who will perform it
  • Your target date and any customer or contract deadline driving it
  • Recurring needs: annual SOC 2 renewals or ISO surveillance audits across the three-year certification cycle

Evaluation criteria

Score every response against the same criteria, agreed before the first proposal arrives.

Eligibility and independence

The firm must be qualified to issue the report you need and must not have designed or run the controls it is auditing. Treat this as pass or fail before any scoring.

Relevant audit experience

Experience with organizations of your size, sector and technology stack, so auditors understand cloud services, CI/CD pipelines or clinical systems without a long education.

Evidence approach

How evidence is requested and collected, whether the firm can work with a compliance platform you already use, and how sampling is done.

Report acceptance

Whether the customers or partners who asked for the report will accept this firm's report or certificate.

Timeline and price

Ability to meet your date and total cost including fieldwork, travel and future years.

Eligibility and independence are a gate, not a score. Among eligible firms, a reasonable start is to weight experience and evidence approach most heavily, then acceptance and timeline, then price. Adjust before issuing the RFP.

The template's scoring matrix, ready to use

These are the starting weights published in the download. Adjust them, score up to three bidders and compare weighted totals as responses come in.

Scoring matrix

Score each bidder from 1 to 5. Totals are weighted and shown out of 100.

Gate before scoring: Eligibility and independence are a pass or fail gate: only firms allowed to issue the report you need are scored.

CriterionWeight
Relevant audit experience in your sector and framework
%
Evidence approach and project management
%
Acceptance of the report by whoever asked for it
%
Timeline fit and capacity
%
Price and expense terms
%
Weighted total100%
60
60
60

Questions to ask every bidder

Ask the same questions of every vendor and require written answers, so responses can be compared line by line.
  • Are you qualified to issue the report or certificate we need? Please provide evidence such as licensing, accreditation or PCI SSC listing.
  • Have you or any affiliate provided consulting or implementation services to us that would affect independence?
  • Who will lead the audit, and what experience do they have with organizations like ours?
  • How will you request evidence, and do you integrate with compliance automation platforms?
  • For SOC 2 Type 2, what observation periods do you support for a first-year report?
  • How do you handle exceptions and deviations found during fieldwork, and when will we hear about them?
  • What is included in your price, and what would cause it to change?
  • What does the follow-on relationship look like for annual renewals or surveillance audits?

Red flags in a response

Any one of these is worth a follow-up question. Several together usually mean the bidder is not the right fit.

The same firm sets up and audits

A firm that writes your policies and implements your controls cannot independently audit them. Bundled "readiness plus audit" offers deserve close questioning about who does what.

Certification that does not exist

There is no official HIPAA certification, and a SOC 2 report is an attestation, not a certificate. Offers that blur these points signal a firm customers may not trust.

Unrealistic timelines

A Type 2 report needs an observation period. A promise of a Type 2 report in a few weeks from a standing start is not credible.

Unaccredited ISO certificates

Certificates from bodies with no recognised accreditation may not be accepted by your customers. Check before you sign.

How to run this RFP

  1. Confirm what the requester will accept

    Ask the customer or regulator driving the audit exactly which report, framework version and scope they need.
  2. Run a readiness or gap assessment

    Fix design gaps before an auditor finds them. This can be done internally or by a separate advisor.
  3. Issue the RFP to eligible firms only

    Pre-qualify by licensing, accreditation or listing so you are not scoring firms that cannot deliver.
  4. Interview the audit lead

    Meet the person who will run fieldwork, not only the sales team.
  5. Plan evidence collection

    Agree the evidence list, owners and dates at kickoff so fieldwork is not delayed by missing artefacts.

Compliance Audit RFP: Frequently Asked Questions

Can GuardsArm perform our SOC 2 audit?

SOC 2 reports must be issued by a licensed CPA firm. Our team helps with readiness, gap remediation, internal audit and evidence preparation, and works alongside the audit firm you choose.

Do we need a readiness assessment before the audit?

It is not required, but it is the cheapest way to find control design gaps before they become exceptions in a report. First-time audits benefit most.

What is the difference between SOC 2 Type 1 and Type 2?

Type 1 reports on whether controls are suitably designed at a point in time. Type 2 also tests whether they operated effectively over a period. Most customers ultimately ask for Type 2.

How does the ISO/IEC 27001 certification cycle work?

Initial certification has two stages: a stage 1 review of documentation and readiness, then a stage 2 audit of implementation. Certificates typically run for three years with surveillance audits in between and a recertification audit at the end.

Can one RFP cover several frameworks?

Yes, if one firm is qualified for all of them. Ask bidders to price each framework separately and to explain how they would reuse evidence across them.

Need help with vendor selection?

Our team can help you tighten the scope, review vendor responses against your criteria and prepare questions for shortlist interviews.