Executive Summary
Managed detection and response is one of the most useful services a mid-size organization can buy, and one of the hardest to compare. Providers use the same words for very different things. One proposal is a staffed operations centre that investigates and contains threats at 3 a.m. Another is software that emails you an alert and waits.
The difference shows up only when something goes wrong. IBM's 2026 research put the average time to identify and contain a breach in Canada at 205 days. The purpose of this service is to turn that into hours, and whether a provider can do it depends on a handful of things a buyer can test before signing.
Buy the outcome, not the dashboard. The outcome is a real intrusion noticed, investigated and contained by a person, at any hour, with evidence you can read afterward.
This guide gives you the questions, the scoring model and the contract terms to make that comparison properly.
Key findings:
- The market sells four different things under similar names. Decide which one you need before reading proposals.
- Authority to act is the dividing line. A provider that cannot isolate a device or disable an account without reaching you is a notification service.
- Ask who owns the platform. A provider that builds and operates its own detection stack can tune it to you. One that resells a vendor's can only pass tickets along.
- Coverage gaps cause most missed detections: unmonitored cloud identity, servers without agents, and anything operational.
- Price follows scope. Compare on what is monitored, what is done about it and how fast, never on headline cost.
Inside the whitepaper
What you are actually buying
Four service types overlap in marketing and differ in substance.
Ten questions that separate providers
These questions are written to produce answers you can verify. Ask for a demonstration or a document for each.
Scoring proposals
Proposals rarely describe the same scope, which makes price comparison misleading. Score capability first, then cost.
Contract terms and the first ninety days
The contract is where marketing language becomes an obligation. Six terms deserve attention.
Key Takeaways
- 1.Decide which service you need first. Managed SIEM, managed EDR, MDR and managed SOC differ mainly in who investigates and who acts.
- 2.Authority to contain a threat without waiting for you is the feature that determines the outcome. Get the permitted actions in writing.
- 3.Ask who builds and operates the detection platform. A provider running its own stack can tune detections to your environment.
Read the full whitepaper
15 pages with every chapter, table, checklist and the phased plan. Tell us where to send it and download it straight away.
